Warning, if you haven’t seen This Is Us lately, then this article contains spoilers.

Last night, Milo Ventimiglia, star of the hit drama This Is Us, appeared on Jimmy Kimmel Live, and of course, his character Jack’s untimely death came up.

Recently, it was revealed that the beloved character was killed in a tragic Crock-Pot accident. As he explains to Kimmel, fans regularly approach him and feel compelled to tell him just how much his fictional death has affected them.

Heads up: The clip contains some somewhat strong language.