True crime has long been a cultural fixation, gripping audiences with stories of grisly murders, unsolved mysteries and psychological intrigue. From podcasts like Crime Junkie to the new Netflix docuseries such as American Murder: Laci Peterson, true crime content has surged in popularity, drawing millions into its web of suspense and horror.
But for Christians, the question arises: Is this obsession with darkness and evil really something we should be indulging in? Reflecting on scriptural calls to set our minds on what is pure, honorable and commendable, it may be time for a collective pause to consider the spiritual and moral implications of our entertainment choices.
The Rise of True Crime
True crime is not a new phenomenon; its roots trace back centuries. From public executions in ancient Greece to the sensationalized crime reports of the 17th and 18th centuries, humanity’s fascination with criminal acts has been a long-standing narrative. With the advent of the printing press, stories of crime were among the first widely distributed forms of media. Fast forward to today, and true crime has evolved into a full-fledged industry, with millions of followers on YouTube, Spotify and major streaming platforms like Netflix, Hulu and Max. The genre’s widespread appeal shows no signs of waning as creators churn out podcasts, documentaries, and even merchandise dedicated to the latest shocking crime story.
The Ethical Dilemmas of Consuming True Crime
While some argue that true crime content can raise awareness about injustices, help solve cold cases, or simply provide an escape from daily life, there are significant ethical concerns to consider. One of the primary arguments against the consumption of true crime is the potential harm it inflicts on the victims and their families. Often, these productions delve into gruesome details that can retraumatize survivors or those who lost loved ones to violence. Imagine having the most tragic moment of your life dissected and sensationalized for entertainment. The pain of reliving those moments, exacerbated by a public constantly consuming and critiquing the details, can be overwhelming.
Furthermore, there is a troubling trend of glamorizing and romanticizing the perpetrators of these crimes. Take the troubling TikTok trend of romanticizing convicted murderer Wade Wilson. Online users are ignoring the realities of his crimes because media attention has focused on his looks. This directly hurts his victims by minimizing their tragic deaths. Romanticizing conventionally attractive killers is, unfortunately, not new.
Serial killers like Ted Bundy and Jeffrey Dahmer have been the subjects of Netflix series that, while not outright glorifying their actions, inevitably turn them into larger-than-life figures. When Hollywood casts attractive actors like Zac Efron or Evan Peters to play these roles, it can blur the line between villain and antihero, leading to dangerous misconceptions and even fan followings for real-life criminals. This not only disrespects the memory of the victims but also fosters a distorted view of evil.
A Call for Christians to Reevaluate
For Christians, there is a higher standard to consider. Philippians 4:8 urges believers to focus on whatever is “true, noble, right, pure, lovely, admirable, excellent or praiseworthy.” The question then becomes: Does true crime fit within these parameters?
The genre often thrives on the shock value of human depravity, and while it might be compelling, it certainly doesn’t align with the biblical call to dwell on things that uplift the spirit. Engaging in content that glorifies or normalizes violence, trauma, and sin conflicts with the pursuit of a Christ-centered life.
Additionally, true crime consumption can desensitize viewers to the reality of suffering and evil. Instead of prompting compassion or justice, it can numb the heart, making real-life tragedies feel more like storylines than the profound human experiences they are. Christians are called to be the salt and light of the world, but immersing oneself in darkness for entertainment can dull that light.
With all entertainment, it is essential to ask whether our media consumption brings us closer to God or if it clouds our perspective, causing us to lose sight of what is truly valuable.
Navigating True Crime Content Responsibly
This isn’t to say that all true crime content is inherently wrong or that Christians should completely abstain from it. The key lies in discernment and intentionality. Some true crime productions focus on honoring the victims and advocating for justice, rather than sensationalizing the perpetrators. For instance, documentaries that highlight systemic failures or advocate for missing and exploited individuals can serve a greater purpose beyond entertainment. However, the onus is on the viewer to critically assess whether the content aligns with their values and contributes to a greater good.
Before pressing play on the next true crime episode, consider the motivations behind your interest. Are you seeking understanding, awareness or simply indulging in a morbid curiosity? Reflect on how the content affects your thoughts, attitudes and even your spiritual health. Would you feel comfortable if the content involved a story close to you or your loved ones? Would it feel respectful, compassionate and aligned with the principles of your faith?
If you can’t answer those questions in a way you’re happy with, it might be better to skip the series altogether.
A Different Path Forward
In a culture that is increasingly desensitized to violence and moral ambiguity, Christians have the opportunity to set a different standard. By choosing to consume media that aligns with biblical values, believers can honor the call to purity and righteousness. This might mean turning off the latest docu-series in favor of content that inspires, educates and uplifts. It could also involve advocating for more responsible storytelling that respects the dignity of victims and seeks justice without glorification of evil.
Ultimately, the goal is not to shame or police others’ entertainment choices but to encourage a deeper reflection on how those choices shape us. As believers, it’s about asking whether our media consumption helps us become more Christ-like and whether it reflects our commitment to living out our faith in every aspect of life. True crime may hold a captivating allure, but the call to set our minds on higher things remains far more compelling and eternally rewarding.
