Worship music isn’t exactly what most people expect when they tune into American Idol. But in recent seasons, more and more contestants have used the stage to bring something real, raw and faith-filled—and the results have been unforgettable. These five moments didn’t just showcase vocal talent. They hit something deeper.
1. Roman Collins Duets with CeCe Winans on “Goodness of God”
This wasn’t just a duet—it was a masterclass. Roman Collins, already known for his powerhouse gospel vocals, held his own next to gospel royalty CeCe Winans in a performance that felt more like Sunday night revival than primetime television. The harmonies soared, the emotions ran high and for a few minutes, the Idol stage felt like holy ground.
2. Abi Carter Sings UNITED’s “Oceans (Where Feet May Fail)”
“Oceans” has been covered to death, but Abi Carter somehow made it feel brand new. Her version was stripped back and intimate, leaning into the song’s quiet tension rather than belting for attention. It was haunting in the best way—less like a worship setlist throwback and more like a whispered prayer in real time.
3. Canaan James Hill Sings Marvin Sapp’s “Never Would Have Made It”
Canaan brought the kind of old-school gospel depth that rarely makes it onto mainstream TV. There was no polish for the cameras—just a deep, resonant voice singing a song that clearly meant something to him. It wasn’t about perfection. It was about presence. And it showed. Though it was eliminated before making it to the Top 8, his Gospel-centered performances will go down in American Idol history.
4. Carsen Webb Sings Elevation Worship’s “More Than Able”
Carsen didn’t overdo it, and that’s exactly why it worked. “More Than Able” is a modern worship anthem with plenty of room for vocal theatrics, but she kept it grounded and personal. The result was a performance that felt both worshipful and effortlessly cool—a rare combination, especially in a competition setting.
5. Jennifer Jeffries Sings an Original Song Called “Change My Ways”
Auditioning with a self-written worship song is a bold move. Jennifer made it count. “Change My Ways” wasn’t flashy or overly produced—it was raw, honest and deeply moving. There was something refreshing about seeing someone share their faith in a way that didn’t feel forced. Just one voice, one piano and one vulnerable, Spirit-filled moment.
