How Valid Are Christian Stereotypes?

The facts about 5 Christian stereotypes.

BY DARGAN THOMPSON GOD / CHURCH October 15, 2013

Ask a random person their perception of Christians and you’ll probably hear a few common themes.

Christians are white southerners who hate Obama and refuse to believe in science. They’re judgmental and hypocritical. They act like they’re better than everyone else but have the same divorce rate as non-Christians.

Even within the Church, we often perpetuate these stereotypes even as we fight them. But how true are these commonly accepted statements? Not all of them are easily quantifiable, but a look at some numbers may surprise us—and show us where we need to work for change.

Christians are Republican

In many American churches, especially in the South, it’s assumed: If you’re a born again, Bible-believing Christian, you vote Republican.

After all, if you really love Jesus you must vote for the party that opposes abortion and gay marriage, right?


And yes, there are more Christian Republicans than Democrats, but the gap may not be as wide as we’re led to believe. A 2008 Barna study found 51 percent of Republicans have spiritual beliefs that qualify them as “born again” Christians. Significantly fewer Democrats hold the same beliefs, but it’s still a pretty high amount: 38 percent.

Furthermore, Pew Research Center found 81 percent of Republicans agree with three religious value statements (“Prayer is an important part of my daily life,” “we will all be called before God at Judgement Day” and “I never doubt the existence of God”), but 62 percent of Democrats also agree with the statements.

Really it comes down to preference and which issues individual voters view as most important. Each party has stances that line up with the “Christian” worldview and stances that don’t.

So while a larger percentage of Christians tend to be Republican, it may not be as polarized as we think.

And of course, this stereotype leaves out Christians who live outside of the U.S. Which brings us to …

Christianity is Mainly an American Thing

“God Bless America!” American Christians often say, sing, tweet or slap on bumper stickers. America is a “Christian nation” we say, and within the Church we often act like America is the epicenter of modern Christianity.

The U.S. still has the largest number of Christians of any country, with over 246 million people who identify as Christians—almost 80 percent of the U.S. population. But there are 2.18 billion Christians around the world. And only 11.3 percent of those live in the U.S.

Percentage-wise, there are several countries that outrank the U.S. in numbers, such as the Democratic Republic of Congo, where almost 96 percent of the population is Christian.

“Christians are … so far-flung, in fact, that no single continent or region can indisputably claim to be the center of global Christianity,” Pew Research Center reports. So while the idea of America being a “Christian nation” may have some historical veracity, it leaves out the global nature of the faith.

Christians Think They’re Better Than Everyone Else / Are Hypocritical

It’s easy to dismiss extreme examples such as Westboro Baptist Church, but the reality is that the Gospel is easy to express, but hard to live out. As much as Christians want to deny this claim, there’s some sadly ample evidence to back it up.

While it’s impossible to truly know people’s hearts, a Barna Group study sheds some light on the average Christian’s motivations. The group did a study to see if Christians were more like Jesus or like Pharisees, asking Christians 10 questions that showed Christ-like actions and attitudes (“I listen to others to learn their story before telling them about my faith,” “I see God-given value in every person, regardless of their past or present condition”), and 10 questions that showed Pharisaical attitudes and actions (“I don’t talk about my sins or struggles. That’s between me and God,” “I feel grateful to be a Christian when I see other people’s failures and flaws”).

The results are discouraging. 51 percent showed Pharisaical attitudes and actions while just 14 percent showed Christ-like attitudes and actions. 21 percent showed Christ-like attitudes but Pharisaical actions.

It’s high time we stopped denying it (“I’m not like those Christians!”) and owned up to the fact that we, like everyone else, are broken and sinful human beings desperately in need of a savior. The truth of the message shouldn’t be in how perfect Christians are—it should be in how reliant they are on their Savior.

Christians Don’t Care About Science

You may have heard the 7 percent statistic thrown around when it comes to the number of scientists who believe in a personal god.

That number comes from a 1998 survey sent out to 517 members of the U.S. National Academy of Sciences from the biological and physical sciences (and received back from roughly half of them).

The fact that this number is based off 300 or so of America’s “leading” scientists begs the question of causation or correlation. In other words, are the best scientists less likely to believe, or are the scientists who do believe less likely to be a part of the NAS?

A 2009 Pew survey of members of the American Association for the Advancement of Science found 33 percent of scientists believe in God and 18 percent more don’t believe in God but do believe in some sort of “higher power.”

This is better than the 7 percent statistic, but it still shows that scientists are much less likely than the wider population to believe in God. It’s something worth looking into—and working to change. Science isn’t faith’s enemy.

Christians Have The Same Divorce Rates As Those Outside the Church

Another statistic that’s often thrown around inside and outside the Church is that those within the Church have the same divorce rate as non-Christians.

A study in the Journal of Religion and Society found that Christians have a slightly lower divorce rate (37 percent) than non-Christians (44 percent). The rates varied between traditions and were significantly lower among those with frequent church attendance.

For example, the divorce rate among non-active mainline protestants was 39 percent between 1980 and 2009, but among those who attended services regularly, it was 26 percent. Regularly attending Catholics had the lowest rate of 21 percent (which may have to do with the strict rules about divorce in the Catholic Church). And those with no religion had a rate of 50 percent.

The numbers are lower than is generally perceived, but they should still give us pause before we get to judgmental of our culture’s view of marriage.

Just like with any group, stereotypes of Christians often exist for a reason, and while we as individuals may not be able to change perceptions of the whole, we can certainly seek to live a life that defies stereotypes—a life given wholly to a God who defies every stereotype.

Dargan Thompson

DARGAN THOMPSON

Dargan is a former RELEVANT editor turned freelancer. Find her online at darganthompson.com or follow her extremely random train of thought on Twitter @darganthompson.

6 thoughts on “How Valid Are Christian Stereotypes?

  1. Excellent article Dargan T.! It’s so true that I can defy stereotypes by how I live and respond. Amazingly, the Scripture says, “And these three remain: faith, hope and love. But the greatest of these is love” (1 Cor. 13:13).
    Sadly, many of us who profess Christ largely miss that. Opinions are pushed, rather than humble submission to Christ. I’ve been there. It’s an easy place to go. I can locate and pull a scripture verse out of context to support virtually any opinion… I’m reminded how Native Americans warn not to judge another until you walk a mile in their moccasins. We only think we know about an issue, until we or a loved one experiences HIV, cancer, abortion, abuse, prison, gender issues, etc. And even then, our nature can push us to one-sidedness. Oh that we would wake up and let God be God. After the hell of a life I’ve walked through, much of it self-inflicted, today I realize that faith means nothing, unless motivated by love. Not my own, but God’s.

  2. Jim,
    In regards to the gun laws, the right to bare arms (the second amendment to the US Constitution) is woven into the very fabric of our nation for the very reason President Obama is seeking to abolish or neuter it— so that the citizen can defend them self from an oppressive government. It’s one of the reasons why the Revolutionary War happened. If you look through history the first step any oppressive government or regime did was to take away an individuals ability to defend themselves. This is why many citizens oppose the Federal Government infringing on their right to bare arms. It’s so much more than a hobby as you put it, and more closely related to the fabric of the American experiment of living a life self determined with liberty. Also, your statistic of thousands of lives being destroyed every year isn’t accurate, but I digress…that is an entirely different conversation to have for another time.

    In regards to Obamacare— that piece of legislation is too complex to give you a simple, straight answer, and the summary that it simply helps the poor is dramatically over simplifying the issue. There is so much unknown about it still that it’s too early to really make any emphatic statements about it other than the areas that clearly violate the Constitution (regardless of what the Supreme Court decided).

    In regards to the Statue of Liberty, many of the founding fathers of this nation were believing men, but did not set out to create a Christian nation, but rather a nation where every man had the ability to determine for them self how they would seek God, not told or commanded what to believe or think by an oppressive regime. This is why the separation of Church and State exists— to keep Government out of our churches, not to keep our faith or moral structures out of society. The Statue of Liberty doesn’t represent a goddess of liberty in the American psyche, she represents Liberty itself, the right to live self determined with a government that protects that liberty.

    I hope I have provided some answers to your questions 🙂

  3. just because christianity is a global religion doesn’t mean that the majority of our policies are created with christians in mind. that is a ridicules assertion to make. There are 1.57 billion muslims

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CURRENT ISSUE

1K Shares
Share1K
+1
Tweet
Share
Email