Are Muslim Refugees Really a Threat to American Christianity?

The threat of ISIS and Sharia in an age of Christian confusion.


If you’ve read C.S. Lewis’ landmark series, The Chronicles of Narnia, the books likely influenced you in no small way. In The Magician’s Nephew from that series, there’s a scene I can’t get out of my mind.

When Aslan the lion speaks to the creatures of Narnia and to the human children who visited there, they heard his voice: good, strong, kind, magical. Yet one character, Uncle Andrew, simply would not feel welcomed or joyful in Narnia’s flourishing, then-peaceful world. Aslan explained:

“I cannot comfort him … he has made himself unable to hear my voice. If I spoke to him, he would hear only growlings and roarings. Oh, Adam’s sons, how cleverly you defend yourselves against all that might do you good!”

When Aslan crowns the first King and Queen of Narnia, just a few pages later, he charges them with this benediction:

“Be just and merciful and brave. The blessing is upon you.”

Far From Narnia

We live in a decidedly un-Narnia-like world. It is full of wars, corruption, abuse and antagonism that parades as “that’s just the way things are.” Yet there are still movements of hope, goodness and flourishing.

The tune of society is largely pessimism and anxiety, crowded by what-ifs and entrenched in the practice of distancing from those who are different. It’s especially perplexing to hear the siren songs of many Christians: defensive, reactionary, insular.

An example of this is recent rallies against allowing Muslim refugees into American cities. A number of Christians are asking, “How would America and Christianity survive against such threats as Islam and ISIS?” Marginalized are voices that sound like the strong and kind God of the Bible, whose message to His people is, “Be just and merciful and brave. The blessing is upon you.”

Have we cleverly defended ourselves against all that might do us good?

Christian Concerns

In several conversations with friends and family—and the social media flurry that cites more opinions than facts and faith—I’ve come across more Christians resistant and even vitriolic toward Muslims—whether Muslims of the moderate majority or radically violent minority.

Voices of some Christian leaders sound more like bitter political candidates. One such voice in the fray is Tony Perkins of the Family Research Council, a political lobbying group. Perkins declares sensitivity and diversity are modern unnecessities, and he broadly opposes allowing Muslims into the United States because he believes most of them want to destroy it and enact Sharia law.

For being a Christian minister and leader of an organization whose mission is “to advance faith, family and freedom in public policy and the culture from a Christian worldview,” Mr. Perkins doesn’t seem to reference, in this article, much (or any) of the Bible and God’s heart on the matters of immigrants, refugees or people who do not believe what Christians do. Perhaps that’s because his agenda hasn’t taken into account God’s agenda.

Muslim Sentiments

Let’s begin with the facts and then move into the realm of faith.

I have to say I like Mr. Perkins’ catchy article title (“How Do You Solve a Problem Like Sharia” made me hum the Sound of Music tune). Certainly, Sharia law sounds like a terrible system for anyone to live under, just like other oppressive government structures that soil human dignity and freedom. I do not want Sharia law in the U.S., nor do I want any form of government-run religious laws oppressing anyone, anywhere.

Thankfully, a wide majority of Western-influenced Muslims do not support Sharia. The CSP poll mentioned by Mr. Perkins was sourced by a routinely misinformed man who’s been proven highly inaccurate and conspiratorial on multiple counts. According to a recent Pew Study, a sizable portion of Muslims living in already oppressive nations are in favor of Sharia (likely because they’re already living in it); however, the portion is significantly smaller in European nations to which some have immigrated. Additionally:

“Muslims mostly say that suicide bombings and other forms of violence against civilians in the name of Islam are rarely or never justified, including 92 percent in Indonesia and 91 percent in Iraq. In the United States, a 2011 survey found that 86 percent of Muslims say such tactics are rarely or never justified.”

Muslim spokespeople in the U.S. are aware of this, and adamantly oppose radicalized, violent wings of Islam and are working against it while not retaliating against the hate they’ve received simply for being moderate Muslims.

There is a way to disagree with the religious and governmental worldview of some and still treat them like humans. Thankfully, some Christian leaders are recognizing the level of hate against Muslims has to stop—for the love of God and people made in His image.

The Survival of Christianity

To answer Americans and Christians in their fear of Muslims, both moderate and radical: Even though I’m aware of the extremity of Sharia law and its implications, yes, I believe Christianity can and would absolutely survive despite it.

The Church has already survived radical oppression and opposing ideology, and she will again.

I believe that because Christianity has historically survived the occupation under the Roman Empire, the convoluted Middle Ages, the violent uprising between Catholics and Protestants in Europe in the 1500s and 1600s. Some German churches remained faithful even when the Nazi regime tried to dismantle them for failing to subscribe to their hateful, bastardized version of Christian teachings.

Interestingly, Christianity already survived severe restrictions and Sharia law under oppressive Islamic societies in the 700s through the 14th century in the Middle East.

Today around the world, the Church is alive and flourishing in places like North Korea, Sudan, Pakistan, Eritrea, Nigeria, Vietnam, Kenya, India, Ethiopia, China and more—despite restrictive and even oppressive violent government policies and practices against Christians.

But this isn’t news to God. Early Church leaders wrote about persecution: “The oftener we are mown down by you, the more in number we grow; the blood of Christians is seed” for the growth of God’s people.

Most of all, I believe the Church will endure because Jesus promised, “I will build my church.”

Yes, the world has always been a dangerous place for followers of Jesus. Thankfully, He knows how dangerous it is. That’s why He invites us to live, not in a spirit of fear, but in His Spirit—with love that is more powerful than violence, with forgiveness that is more powerful than hate.

How God Told Us to Solve the Problem

As followers of Jesus, we can enjoy America and the Constitution and all that comes with being a citizen (that’s another conversation), but our primary allegiance is not to a nation; our goal is not to persuade the world of the American way of life. The writers of the Bible insisted that we are citizens of the kingdom of God, and aligning our values and actions with the kingdom of God is our goal for changing the world.

Following the way of Jesus, we see Muslims not as enemies, but as people we are commanded by God to love and reach with a life-changing message. Like we were once enemies of God and He welcomed us, we can invite Muslims to experience reconciliation with God. If the Gospel is for us, it is for them, too. He shows no partiality.

To answer Mr. Perkins’ question, “How do you solve a problem like Sharia?” I suppose Jesus would answer with radical, life-changing love in the message of the Gospel. After all, He knows a thing or two about facing a violent government system, turning unjust laws on their head and living as a child of God.

Even in the face of danger, Christian faith gives us hope because our God has conquered death. As one author said it: “Death is a thing empires worry about, not a thing resurrection people worry about.”

Friends, let us remember who we are and who we follow.

Be just and merciful and brave. The blessing is upon you.


is a writer in Greenville, South Carolina, and is the author of The Variable Life: Finding Clarity and Confidence in a World of Choices, from which this article is adapted. Visit to find more.

One thought on “Are Muslim Refugees Really a Threat to American Christianity?

  1. With all due respect, but concerning the issue of the current refugee crisis too many Christians have been primarily concerned about being seen as “good” and “compassionate” – being self-righteous – and somehow have ended up ignoring inconvenient problems and facts.

    Christians certainly must do whatever they can to help refugees and spread the gospel to them and should also treat them as humanely as possible. However, it’s ludicrous to overlook the impact that receiving huge influxes of them in the West can have. Many of them do have a culture and a religious view that clashes directly with the Christian one. And once they come, many of they will not simply accept the norms of the new country/culture and respect it. Rather, they will try to reshape it, which means, among other things, importing practices such as Sharia Law and making them mainstream. That has happened in France and will happen in Germany and other countries too as the share of the muslim population in those countries increases more and more.

    Second, ofterntimes people are not truthful when answering delicate questions in surveys such as support for Sharia Law. There is social desirability bias involved. Chances are that the support for Sharia Law is much higher than it has been reported.

    Third, the fact that Christianity has survived countless persecutions in different places and times does not mean that Christians should accept persecutions blindlessly. Especially if they know it can be avoided, that it does not need to happen.

    Fourth, the refugee crisis is not just a “moral” problem, but a political one with important public policy ramifications. Accepting huge masses of refugees has taken a toll on the amount of public service provisions that European government can provide. In Germany the police has been underfunded and overwhelmed. There are not enough funds, people, and infrastructure in place to take care of so many people coming in in such a short period. Who pays for all that help? Local citizens, including Christians. The impact of stretched thin public services has already materialized: for instance, crime in Germany has gone up, as well as cases of sexual harrassment.

    Finally, much has been said about the obligation that the West, especially Christian countries, has at receiving refugees and taking care of them. What about the obligation that (supposedly) felow muslim countries in the Middle East have with them? Why are not Saudi Arabia, Oman, UAE, Bahrain, Kuwait and Qatar (many of them rich countries) receiving refugees?

    In sum, many well-intentioned and loving fellow Christians are sometimes so eager to help refugees, directly or indirectly, that many of them end up ignoring reality and somehow try to sugarcoat its most undesirable parts. Yes, we must be obedient to the Lord and be compassionate towards the refugees. This is an awful humanitarian crisis that cannot and must not be ignored. However, we must not ignore some realities, unfortunately unpleasant, about the nature os islam, the identity and worldview of many of the refugees, and the consequences that they can have – and are having – in our societies right now.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *